Maybe you should just hit up Andy for a date and see what happens. If he isn't out of his shell by then, (with relief of knowing how you think of him as datable) then I don't know what will get him out! (although the way he sounds, he might be nervous on the date anyway.) I'd recommend something outgoing to do. Not a "sit at a movie" type date. Something fun you can both do that will loosen him up. He might be a great guy. Shy, but great. Or he could be a shy uncaring jerk. Guess it's up to you to decide if you want to find out.

Don't feel bad about the "out of character" thing. If it wasn't so far fetched, and you didn't feel that way, you wouldn't have done it. So it really is within your character to do. Just because the situation that presented itself was in a bar, doesn't mean your a bar skank! :-P

__________________
3 out of 2 people have problems with fractions.