I think it's tacky to give someone an engagement ring for Christmas or for their birthday.

Am I completely alone in this?

__________________
I think all women really want is to be proven wrong about men.

Hmm... why is it tacky? I bet lots of women out there would love to get an engagement ring, no matter what day, and let's face it: jewelry beats a vaccuum cleaner or a bottle of perfume.

__________________

i don't see whats tacky about that. i thought my s.o would do that for my 21st but he said he's not. damn it.

he said he's got it all under control.

perfumes ok. diamonds are better. but i usuall perfer the cash.

My ex-husband gave me an engagement ring for my birthday. For some reason, it bugged me. I guess I wanted it to be an occasion of it's own, you know?

__________________
I think all women really want is to be proven wrong about men.

It's not that.

It's that the engagement should be at least unexpected. Birthdays/holidays are gift-giving days anyway. Be original.

__________________

birthday or not... a few thousands dollars isn't something that you can just give any day of the year. it takes time to save up for these things and by pulling it out on your birthday only adds to the larger ring size that he was able to get.

in other words, would you have cared for a separate birthday present with a smaller rock on your finger??

raverboy

__________________
...this is just my perspective on the situation...

Quite a random question... I think I understand where you're coming from, though. I don't think it's necessarily cheesy, but cheap. And besides, if you're in a situation like Gigabitch's, you remember it every year, for the rest of your life. Every year, you'll have that one bitchy friend that mentions to you "Hey, didn't you get engaged on your birthday? *snicker"

__________________
If you stare at a white pixel long enough, you notice the throbbing red, green, and blue elements that create it.

If you stare at a fuzzy blanket long enough with your eye so close it goes out of focus, just look at the sparkles; you can see it on the cellular level.

I have never in my life heard anyone snicker about being propsed to on either their birthday or Christmas.

__________________

I don't feel like giving Amy a dumb ring.

Rings are dumb, and I never want to have to wear one.

__________________

I'm finally working class and I don't even shave my head no more.

Most girls want SOME sort of ring. We like the symbolism.

__________________

They're too expensive. Why would I wanna waste money on something so trivial? I really don't comprehend the expensive jewelry and fancy debt-inducing weddings.

__________________

I'm finally working class and I don't even shave my head no more.

They don't have to be expensive. You can pick up a plain gold band for pretty cheap.

__________________

or you can put 50 cents into those quarter machines and hope that the little plastic bubble thing that you receive has a ring inside of it. is that doesn't work, cracker jack boxes usually will come with a ring. it's bit pricier than the 50 cent machine, but atmost you won't spend more than 5 bucks.

raverboy

__________________
...this is just my perspective on the situation...

If you get your girlfriend a 50 cent ring for your wedding, I'm pretty sure she'd shove it up your ass.

__________________
If you stare at a white pixel long enough, you notice the throbbing red, green, and blue elements that create it.

If you stare at a fuzzy blanket long enough with your eye so close it goes out of focus, just look at the sparkles; you can see it on the cellular level.

Well, I was proposed to around my birthday. Chris took me to Disney for my birthday, we spent the weekend. But it was like 2 days after my birthday. Anyway, what a great way he proposed. Ya know in all the parks they take your pic everywhere. So, were standing in front of Cinderella's castle getting ready to snap some more pics and BAM he fell to his knees and prosposed. I was shocked as hell. It was so unexpected and awesome. Its a day I will NEVER forget. The best part was Chris told the photographer he was about to propose so he snapped a ton of shots, it was incredible. We spent a fortune on the pics, but it was worth it.

I guess getting proposed on holidays or birthdays, some women almost expect it, it kinda ruins the element of suprise. But its something you will never forget. I dont find it cheesy, i find it kinda romantic. But I guess it depends on how the guy does the proposing too.

__________________
everything happens for a reason...